Premodern Matchup Matrix
Head-to-head win rates for the top 16 archetypes by meta share. Sources: MTGO Challenge playoff brackets, TopDeck.gg paper event swiss rounds, and Gatherling community league rounds.
Window:
Sources: TopDeck.gg, mtgo · Data since Sep 2026 · 186 matches
| ↓ vs → | Selesnya Enchantress | Mono-Blue Stiflenought | Naya Terragedon | Mono-Red Sligh | Azorius Replenish | Mono-Black Midrange | The Rock | UB Psychatog | Elves | Izzet Sligh | Psychatog | Azorius Stiflenought | Gruul Sligh | Selesnya Land Destruction | 5c Hermit Druid | Simic Stiflenought |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Selesnya Enchantress | 71%17m12-5 (17 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | 36%11m4-7 (11 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m0-3 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m3-0 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m1-3 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | 33%6m2-4 (6 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | ~4m2-2 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | |
| Mono-Blue Stiflenought | 29%17m5-12 (17 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | 44%9m4-5 (9 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | 80%5m4-1 (5 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | ~2m2-0 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m3-1 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | 83%6m5-1 (6 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | 50%6m3-3 (6 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | ~4m1-3 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m0-2 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | 38%8m3-5 (8 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | |
| Naya Terragedon | 64%11m7-4 (11 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | 56%9m5-4 (9 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m2-2 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m2-0 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~3m3-0 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | |
| Mono-Red Sligh | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | 20%5m1-4 (5 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | — | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | |
| Azorius Replenish | ~3m3-0 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m0-2 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m2-0 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m2-2 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m3-0 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | |
| Mono-Black Midrange | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m1-3 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~2m0-2 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~2m2-0 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | |
| The Rock | ~3m0-3 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m2-2 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | |
| UB Psychatog | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | |
| Elves | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | 17%6m1-5 (6 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m1-3 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | |
| Izzet Sligh | ~4m3-1 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | 50%6m3-3 (6 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | |
| Psychatog | 67%6m4-2 (6 matches) — Low sample, 5–7 matches | ~4m3-1 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m0-2 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m0-2 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | |
| Azorius Stiflenought | ~4m2-2 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m2-0 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m2-2 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m2-0 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~4m3-1 (4 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | — | |
| Gruul Sligh | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~1m1-0 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | |
| Selesnya Land Destruction | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | 63%8m5-3 (8 matches) — Medium sample, 8–19 matches | ~3m0-3 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~2m0-2 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | — | |
| 5c Hermit Druid | — | ~3m2-1 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~2m1-1 (2 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | — | — | |
| Simic Stiflenought | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | ~3m0-3 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | ~3m1-2 (3 matches) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | ~1m0-1 (1 match) — Insufficient sample, so no win rate is shown | — | — | — | — | — | — |
Cells show the row archetype's win rate against the column archetype, over the selected window, with the number of matches behind it. Hover any cell for the record.
- High sample (20+ matches)
- Medium sample (8–19 matches)
- Low sample (5–7 matches)
- Insufficient sample (under 5 matches)
Bands are named for the size of the sample, not for confidence: even the strongest band carries a 95% interval around ±20 percentage points. Below 5 matches no win rate is shown at all. How these are calculated